Brown Brothers BBQ: Indulge in Finger-Licking Good BBQ in Canastota

Top categories (Sammies / Plates / Sides & Drinks / Sauces)
Most orders: $10–20

Welcome to Brown Brothers BBQ, a hidden gem nestled at 214 S Peterboro St, Canastota, NY. If you're on the hunt for the most mouthwatering barbecue in the Northeast, look no further. This restaurant takes you on a flavorful journey through the heart of BBQ cuisine with a selection that promises to tantalize your taste buds.

The inviting atmosphere at Brown Brothers BBQ offers a casual dining experience, perfect for family gatherings or a laid-back meal with friends. As you step inside, the rich aromas of smoked meats and savory spices welcome you, promising a feast that will leave your hunger satisfied. The decor is simple yet comfortable, allowing the food to take center stage.

At the heart of the menu are their sensational sammies, each crafted with meticulous care and a devotion to flavor. The standout, Pork Carolina Sammy, features slow-smoked pulled pork piled high on a fluffy brioche roll, lovingly topped with creamy coleslaw. Priced at just US$10.00, it’s a slice of heaven you won’t want to miss. For those craving a kick, the Angry Pig Sammy brings together the perfect marriage of pulled pork and kielbasa, enhanced with pickled jalapenos and a secret homemade Bama sauce at US$13.00.

And for the ultimate indulgence, the Meat Sweats Sammy combines dual flavors of pulled pork and kielbasa with BBQ and beer mustard. With each bite, you’ll experience an explosion of tastes that BBQ lovers dream of. Don't forget to pair your meal with their refreshing sides such as coleslaw, salt potatoes, or BBQ beans, all priced at just US$3.00.

But don’t just take our word for it—customer reviews highlight the incredible dining experience. Howard Long raved about the “perfect” burnt ends and ribs, and Joe Rocco expressed gratitude for the exceptional service during a catering event. Visitors have described the corn chowder as “so much more than corn chowder,” showcasing the creativity and talent of the kitchen at Brown Brothers BBQ.

Whether you're a local or just passing through, Brown Brothers BBQ is more than a pit stop; it’s an experience. With an array of delicious BBQ offerings and a commitment to quality that feels personal, you'll surely be planning your next visit before you've even finished your meal. Savor the flavors and warmth that make this establishment a staple in Canastota!

Ready to indulge your BBQ cravings? Give them a call at (315) 720-0318 or stop by to see what everyone’s been raving about. Your taste buds will thank you!

Delivery

Credit cards
Debit cards

Howard Long

06/12/2025

We stopped in and got food from here for the first time on Saturday 7/5. Everything was great. The burnt ends and ribs perfect. The combo platter kielbasa, chicken and pulled pork was amazing as well. Thank you Brown Brother's BBQ for an excellent meal and we definitely will be back. Can't wait for the brisket.

Joe Rocco

03/12/2025

Brown Brothers catered a family party for 30+ people. As a result of a large event sponsored by Brown Brothers the day before, they ran out of some items that we ordered for our party a few weeks prior. The owner was very professional and called us the day of our party and offered other menu items free of charge. The pulled chicken and corn bread was outstanding. Thank you for stepping up and doing what was right. We will be back.

Carolyn Bush

20/11/2025

Best Cornbread ever!! And the corn chowder is so much more than corn chowder. The smoked chicken in that chowder was perfection. I’m not in town often, but when I am, I’ll be returning here every time!

Lorin Strail

28/10/2025

Brown Brothers BBQ is simply the best! They provided catering for our wedding. They did an amazing job, food was absolutely delicious. Staff was very friendly, we couldn’t have asked for a better experience. Our wedding was over a year ago and people are still asking me regularly who provided the catering because the food was outstanding. 10/10 recommend!!!

Scott L

11/10/2025

Best BBQ in the entire Northeast! Been driving all over the northeast (11or12 states) for the past 2 1/2 years and eaten BBQ throughout. We are from Colorado and have eaten a ton of Texas and KC BBQ as well. Brown Brothers is awesome. Go there. Highly recommend the burnt ends and brisket. All so good. Thanks for having us!

M M

31/08/2025

Stopped for delicious BBQ on hour five of driving route 90 and the slight detour was very worth it. Literally finger-licking good. The pork, coleslaw and sauce were my favorite. Portions are sizable and we took some to go.

Katie Staley

22/08/2025

I was hooked when they were only a food truck! Then they opened their store front. Then I had them cater my son’s graduation party. Pleasant to deal with. Quick service. Delicious smoked meats. Can’t go wrong. Since my son’s grad party, had them cater a work retirement party, and plan to pick up for a family Labor Day party this coming weekend. Prices are shared on their website for their restaurant and catering. They respond to Facebook messages promptly. Definitely a great addition to the community.

Siagny Ortiz

19/08/2025

I was traveling from Massachusetts to Niagara Falls. It so happened that we wanted a town pizza place and ended up here at Brown Brothers. We can't regret the decision to replace pizza with this barbecue. This has been the best barbecue I have ever had. I recommend this 1000% thank you thank you.

Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *