Brown Brothers BBQ Menu (Updated 2026)

Welcome to Brown Brothers BBQ, a hidden gem located at 214 S Peterboro St, Canastota, NY. This establishment has quickly become a local favorite, renowned for its impeccably smoked meats and hearty sandwiches. A must-try is the Pork Carolina Sammy, featuring slow-smoked pulled pork on a brioche roll piled high with creamy coleslaw for just $10. For a fiery twist, dive into the Angry Pig Sammy, combining pulled pork and kielbasa topped with pickled jalapeños and homemade Bama sauce at $13.

The sides, including coleslaw and BBQ beans, are perfect accompaniments at just $3. Customers rave about the rich flavors found in the burnt ends and cornbread, with many promising to return for more. With friendly service and generous portions, every bite at Brown Brothers BBQ feels like a warm welcome back to your favorite barbecue. Don’t miss the chance to indulge in their tangy sauces that elevate each dish to perfection!

The menu emphasizes smoked and pulled pork dishes, with a focus on sandwiches ("Sammies") and combination plates. Sammies are priced from $10 to $13, representing budget-friendly options, while multi-meat BBQ combos in the $18 range serve as premium choices with customizable meat selections. Sides and drinks are offered at lower price points ($2–$3), supporting add-on flexibility. The variety of hearty plates and sandwiches suggests suitability for lunch and dinner occasions.